The Reading Cove
Home | Cove Chat! | Cove Mission | Cove FAQ Corner | Recent and Upcoming Events | "Bonus Book" | Cove Reviews of Last Pick | Cove Grading Scale | Cove Suggestion Corner | Great Links! | Cove History I | Join The Cove
Cove Grading Scale

Yellow Glass Tumbling Childs Block

Blue Tumbling Childs Block

Green Tumbling Childs Block

Tell us how you feel about your reads. Here's a "common ground" scale to let us know how you rate a book...any book!

Horizontal Divider 25

11/10 (A+)  PHENOMENAL!!

Knocked my socks off! Pardon me while I gush...I loved, loved, loved everything about this book!  This was off the charts, beyond perfect, everything I want in a book! It was scrumptiously delicious - one of the best books I've ever read! I will enthusiastically recommend it, and count the author among my personal favorites. This is what reading is all about. I'd treasure a re-read of this book one day!

10/10 (A)  EXCELLENT!

Solid A. Did it have to end? This book was perfection for me. Un-put-downable, and unforgettable. I highly recommend it, would welcome a re-read, and certainly want to read more of the author. Yum!

9/10 (A-)  IMPRESSIVE!

Impressive read! But (for whatever reason) just a *tad* shy of perfect. Still, I could hardly put this wonderful book down and highly recommend it to others! I would love a re-read one day, and would certainly seek out more by this author.

8/10 (B+)  GREAT!

Extremely good read! Had many awesome, memorable moments, and really kept my interest throughout! I warmly recommend it, and look forward to reading more from the author. Probably wouldn't mind reading it again one day!


A solid B. Very enjoyable read. It was engrossing and held my attention. I would recommend it, and I'm absolutely open to more from the author. This was a satisfying book.

6/10 (B-)  GOOD

A good book. I liked it, but I didn't LOVE it. It had some minor flaws, but, overall, it was still good enough to recommend. I'm open to more from the author.


An above average read. This book had its moments (which saved it from a fate worse than C+), but, for me, the overall pulse was mild, and I'm not sure how quickly I'd recommend it. I don't regret the read, and I'm still open to trying something else from the author.

4/10 (C)  AVERAGE

A solid C. Just an average read. This book was merely OK. There was some entertainment value, but (for whatever reason) it missed a little something for me; and certainly didn't keep me up nights. Not saying I wasted my time reading this, but it could've been a lot better. Don't think I'd ever recommend it, but would consider reading it again....if I was bored! If the author was new to me, I don't see myself rushing out to find anymore of his/her work.


Below average read, but acceptable. Can't say I totally regret reading this book, but its flaws got the best of it - I could've spent my time reading something else. Definitely a "be sure to get it from the library" kind of read. It wasn't the worst, but still an overall yawner. I would not recommend it, and I'm now likely to be wary of the author.

2/10 (D)  BAD

Bad read! Very weak and severely flawed. I should've chucked it, but likely stuck it out for a book club discussion! This book took too long to hook me, wasn't at all engaging, and/or bored me to near death. If there were any redeeming aspects to the read, they weren't fleshed out enough for me to enjoy. Getting through was frustrating, I barely made it to the end. Blech. I could never recommend it.

1/10 (F)  AWFUL!

Just awful. I had major problems with this book. If I reached the end, thank God for skimming! In fact, if I hoped it would improve, and read beyond the first 50 or 100 pages, that was a big mistake. The story was painfully boring, transparent, ineffectively told, just plain stupid, or all of the above and then some. Money was wasted on this book. I think I'll be steering clear of the author from now on.


I did not finish. This book was akin to a sleeping pill - pardon me while I yawn....It never captured my attention, and showed no signs of improving. This book didn't pass the 50 (100, etc.) page test for me. I gave it a fair shake, but just wasn't finding the text engaging enough to continue - I had to move on. This could be a great read for someone else, but just wasn't my cup of tea.